Dealing with Dictators: North Korea

Aug 14, 2009

Should you ever deal with dictators? Two American journalists held hostage in North Korea were released as a result of Bill Clinton's recent meeting with Kim Jong-il. Did the positive outcome justify lending credibility to one of the world's worst regimes?

Bill Clinton went to North Korea and met Kim Jong-il, the leader of one of the world's worst regimes.

The visit by a former U.S. president and international celebrity gave global visibility and an aura of equal status to an isolated regime. The greeting and the photo-op, one of history's most affectless pictures, may be all the North wanted.

As a result, two American journalists were released. They were arrested along the China-North Korea border while researching a story and sentenced to 12 years of hard labor.

But should you ever deal with dictators? In this case, did positive outcomes justify lending credibility to bad guys?

Does defining the parameters of negotiations impact the decision?

The mission was labeled and treated as unofficial, however, the trip was probably coordinated with the administration, and Clinton must have had some assurance of success in advance. Furthermore, the private/public line is fine since his spouse is the Secretary of State.

What do you think? Did the U.S. give up too much for the sake of two citizens? Were ethical standards compromised or upheld?

By William Vocke.

To post a comment, go to the Global Ethics Corner slideshow.

You may also like

CREDIT: Abobe/hamara.

SEP 25, 2024 Article

Politico Op-Ed: Walking a Fraying Nuclear Tightrope

In a new op-ed, Carnegie Council President Joel Rosenthal argues that a recommitment to nuclear arms control is nothing short of a moral imperative.

empty United Nations General Assembly hall

MAY 22, 2023 Article

Sitting on the Sidelines: The Global Divide on Ukraine

Carnegie Council President Joel Rosenthal reflects on the global divide in relation to Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

U.S. Army M1A2 Abrams tanks

FEB 6, 2023 Article

Ethics, Escalation, and Engagement in Ukraine and Beyond

Now that HIMAR and Patriot missiles as well as Leopard and Abrams tanks are on the way to Ukraine, NATO unity is at a high ...

未翻译

此内容尚未翻译成您的语言。您可以点击下面的按钮申请翻译。

要求翻译